Category: Economics

  • The Intractable Downfall of Capitalism

    Illustrated through a brief history of Dell Computer Corporation

    Started by Michael Dell in his dorm room at the University of Texas in 1984, Dell Computer Corporation grossed over $3 Billion Dollars in 2013. Although it is rarely mentioned in discussing the history of Dell Computers, it is negligent not to point out that Michael Dell formed the company for his own profit, and not for the benefit of others. He did so against the sage advice of his family, who expected him to continue with college and medical school to become a doctor.

    Dell had developed a new model in the personal computer market – direct sales. It proved to be a hit. Although he initially built the systems himself to sell to college classmates, he eventually hired employees to keep up with the demand.

    Michel left college to continue to build the business. He had picked an industry that was just about to go supernova. And just as things were really starting to roll, along comes the Internet, which was the perfect complement for the Dell direct sales model.

    By this time, the company had gone public, and Michael Dell’s net worth had skyrocketed. A business built with $1000 cash in a dorm room was now one of the big players in the personal computer industry, and had made Michael a billionaire.

    In the earliest days, the company built up operations in the Austin area. As the company grew, operations expanded to Ireland, Malaysia, China, Brazil, and other locations around the world, employing over 100,000 people.

    In 2013, Michael Dell determined to take the company private again. In a cantankerous buyout, Dell and Silver Lake Partners bought out the existing shareholders, and took the company off the stock market. As preparations for the buyout were put in motion, rumors began to circulate that there would be layoffs following the takeover. Many employees had worked for Dell for 15 years or more, and were now fearing for their job.

    Indeed, after the buyout was complete, an announcement was sent to all the employees of the company, offering a generous separation package for anyone who wished to accept a layoff.

    If the downfall of the system hasn’t hit you yet, I’ll spell it out for you. Michael Dell was too lazy to finish school. He took a massive risk, dropping out of school to build computers instead of following a path that would almost certainly have lead to a very comfortable life as a doctor. Then, out of laziness and greed, he hired people to build the systems while he grew the business. I’m not one to speculate, but I can’t help but think that he would never have hired those people if he didn’t think he would make more money for himself that way.

    And thus it continued. Michael Dell’s greed and laziness eventually led to the company having over 100,000 employees throughout the world. Salaries have gone to buy groceries and houses, raise children, and take vacations.

    And that’s really the rub. Greedy, filthy, money-grubbing capitalists can’t seem to make their billions without also providing jobs for others. Oh, and products or services that the public wants.

    If capitalism really worked, people like Michael Dell would be able to get obnoxiously wealthy without having to provide goods and services that other people wanted, and without having to hire employees and making their lives better. Capitalism is a complete disaster.

  • Walmart is Better than Government

    Have you ever noticed that Walmart never fails you? I don’t like Walmart, for a lot of reasons. But I know that every time I go into their stores, I’m going to find the toothbrush that I need, tee shirts with some ridiculous slogan, and a baseball bat.

    Why does Walmart serve all my needs, every time? Is it because they love me? Is it because they are concerned about my welfare? No, it is because they want my money. If they don’t have what I want, I will go across the street to Target. And once I go to Target, I won’t go back to Walmart again until Target fails me.  Walmart has a very strong incentive to always have the things I want.

    This is the funny thing about human nature. Although the government claims to be there to help us, it has very little incentive to actually give us what we want. Meanwhile, we know full well that Walmart is not in business to help us. They are in business for their own personal gain. Yet, they struggle far more energetically to give us what we want than the government does. And Walmart pays it’s employees with money that we freely give, not with taxes that are taken from us with the threat of physical force.

    Maybe it’s time that we stop putting our hope in presidents, or the federal government, or even the state and local governments. Maybe there really is something to this whole “free market” idea.

  • Why Conservatives Should Support Labor Unions

    Why should conservatives support labor unions?  Because they are a natural product of the free market.  Because they are the expression of free people.  Because they are, in fact, a business like any other.

    In a free country, I use my resources in whatever way seems most fitting to me.  That’s a pretty basic tenet of conservative ideology.  For $100, I can buy this quadcopter drone for $49.99, or this quadcopter drone for $4,399.00.  It is entirely my right to decide which product and which vendor best suits my needs.

    Labor is a product.  If I wish to purchase 8 hours of labor, I have to find out what the price is.  If one laborer tells me that he wants $100, and another laborer tells me he wants $140, why should I not be able to choose which product and which vendor I prefer?

    Now imagine that you own a house.  You estimate the value at $3.2 million.  You hire an agent who specializes in high-end housing deals.  The agent lists the house at $3.9 million, and sells it for $3.6 million.  Have you done anything wrong by using a third party to get the best possible deal?  Of course not.

    If I am selling labor, rather than a house, why is it any different for me to hire an agent to get the best possible deal?  I may be a great machinist, or a great plumber, but I may not be a great negotiator.  So why shouldn’t I hire a negotiator to get me the best possible price for the commodity I am offering?

    That’s what a labor union is – a hired agent to get the best possible deal for the purveyor of labor.

    If conservatives want to be philosophically consistent, they must either support labor unions, or admit that liberty is not part of the conservative message.